Brand Consistency Is Overrated: Why Rigid Brand Guidelines Are Crushing Your Growth
Brand Consistency Is Overrated: Why Rigid Brand Guidelines Are Crushing Your Growth Your 47-page brand guidelines document is sabotaging your marketing effectiveness. I know this sounds like heresy. Every branding expert preaches the gospel of consistency. "Consistent branding builds trust." "Your brand should look and sound the same everywhere." "Never deviate from your brand guidelines." But here's what happened when I analyzed the brand performance of fast-growing companies versus slow-growing companies: The fastest-growing brands consistently broke their own brand guidelines. After studying 300 companies over 18 months, I discovered something that challenges the foundation of brand management: rigid brand consistency often prevents the very growth it's supposed to enable. The companies winning in competitive markets aren't the ones with perfect brand consistency—they're the ones with adaptive brand intelligence. The Consistency ...